I have purchased several different goat milk soaps in the past, mostly for gifts and they have all been greatly appreciated. I thought I would try the applejack and peel because I always liked the scent of apples. I gave one to both of my daughters and granddaughter at Easter and they all seemed to enjoy the scent. My one daughter's favorite is the oatmeal and honey and the other uses the unscented goat milk soap as she has allergies but although she has had problems in the past with other soaps she is happy with these. My granddaughter seems to enjoy all I have purchased so far. I haven't used the applejack soap yet, right now I am happy to just have the soap in the bathroom bringing to mind everything apple. I am sure I will like it though I have to admit so far I just love the lilac best, both the soap and lotion. You can close your eyes and picture a garden, not only when you are washing with the soap but the feel of your skin after using the soap and lotion. It is a special treat! I just also like trying the others as well. Plus they make great gifts! Always bring smiles!